Traeger Pro 575 vs. Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24: Which Is Better?

Updated: August 27, 2026

The Traeger Pro 575 vs. Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 decision is not a simple contest between a good grill and a bad one. Both automate pellet feeding and temperature control, but they solve different problems. The Traeger is the cleaner choice for buyers who want phone control and an established smart-grill system. The Camp Chef gives cooks more total rack area and more hands-on utility.

Important model note: This comparison focuses on the original Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 model family, including PG24SG. Do not assume every grill advertised as an “SG 24” has WiFi. Camp Chef sold related versions with different controllers, and retrofit controllers have also been available. Confirm the model number, controller face, and included features before buying new old stock or a used grill.

[wbsgf_offers]

How Was This Pellet Grill Comparison Researched?

This comparison combines my experience owning a Camp Chef SmokePro for several years with current manufacturer documentation for both model families. I have not cooked on the Traeger Pro 575, so I do not claim a side-by-side cooking test.

When I bought my Camp Chef, I compared it directly with a Traeger. I chose the Camp Chef partly because of a Traeger concern at the time, but that particular issue was later corrected. I would not use an old, resolved problem as a reason to reject the Pro 575 today.

The specifications below were checked against the official Traeger Pro 575 support guide and Camp Chef’s PG24SG and PG24SGCB product-manual page. Retail listings for an older grill can contain mixed information, which is why the exact Camp Chef model check matters.

What Is the Main Difference Between the Traeger Pro 575 and Camp Chef SG 24?

The main difference is priorities: the Traeger Pro 575 emphasizes built-in WiFi convenience, while the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 emphasizes cooking capacity and practical grill hardware.

Fast decision: Pick the Traeger if you want to monitor and adjust the grill from your phone without sorting through model variations. Pick the Camp Chef if you regularly need a large upper rack, want two food probes, or value Slide and Grill more than a polished app experience.

Which Pellet Grill Has More Usable Cooking Space?

The Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 has more total cooking space, but most of its numerical advantage comes from the upper rack rather than the main grate.

Traeger’s support guide lists a 418-square-inch main grate and a 154-square-inch upper grate, totaling 572 square inches. Traeger also markets the grill as having 575 square inches. That three-square-inch difference is a naming or rounding detail, not something a buyer will notice while cooking.

The original Camp Chef PG24SG is commonly listed with 429 square inches on the lower grate and 382 square inches above it, for 811 square inches total. Its lower grate is therefore only 11 square inches larger than Traeger’s. The much deeper upper-rack capacity creates the real difference.

This distinction matters. Total square inches can make two grills look farther apart than they feel when cooking one large brisket on the bottom grate. The Camp Chef’s upper rack is most useful for ribs, chicken pieces, sausage, vegetables, and sides that fit its height and temperature zone. It also offers more flexibility when foods finish at different times.

Which grill is better for normal family meals?

The Traeger Pro 575 is large enough for many everyday family cooks, including burgers, chicken, pork chops, vegetables, and several racks of ribs.

Traeger advertises capacity for up to 24 burgers, five rib racks, or four chickens. Those are brand estimates, and actual fit depends on food size and spacing. Still, they show that the Pro 575 is not a tiny pellet grill. If most meals feed two to six people, its smaller chamber may be easier to heat, arrange, and clean than a larger cooker.

Which grill is better for ribs, pork shoulder, and parties?

The Camp Chef SG 24 is the better capacity choice for multiple racks of ribs, more than one pork shoulder, mixed foods, or party cooking.

The extra upper-rack area lets you separate foods and preserve space on the main grate. It will not eliminate the need to rotate food if the grill has hotter zones, but it gives you more options than the Pro 575. Buyers who regularly fill a smoker are more likely to appreciate the Camp Chef than someone cooking for one or two people.

Which Grill Has Better WiFi and Controller Features?

The Traeger Pro 575 is the safer choice when app control is a must because WiFIRE is a documented standard feature of this model.

WiFIRE lets you monitor the grill, adjust its set temperature, and follow the cook through the Traeger app. The grill can still operate at its controller without an internet connection, but remote features depend on a working network and successful app pairing. Like any outdoor smart device, the experience can also depend on WiFi signal strength near the grill.

The Camp Chef side requires more care. The original PG24SG was sold with a conventional controller, while later SG 24 WiFi versions and compatible replacement controllers can create similar-looking listings. Camp Chef’s pellet grill FAQ states that not all of its pellet grills include WiFi. Never pay extra for a Camp Chef listing until the seller shows the controller and confirms the exact model number.

Does the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 have WiFi?

Some SG 24 versions have WiFi, but the name alone does not prove it. Confirm the model number and controller before buying.

If the controller has already been replaced, ask whether the app connects properly and whether the seller still has the original receipt or controller documentation. On a used grill, test every button, both probe ports, the auger, fan, igniter, and shutdown cycle before money changes hands.

Which Pellet Grill Is Better for Smoking and Searing?

Both grills are better suited to controlled smoking and roasting than steakhouse-style searing, but the Camp Chef’s Slide and Grill system gives it the stronger direct-flame option.

The Traeger Pro 575 operates from 165°F to 500°F according to Traeger. That range covers low-and-slow barbecue, poultry, burgers, casseroles, vegetables, and higher-temperature roasting. It does not include Traeger’s Super Smoke mode, and the grill has no dedicated open-flame searing system.

The original Camp Chef SG 24 was designed around a 160°F-to-500°F controller range and a sliding heat-deflector arrangement. With the Slide and Grill lever open, the food can receive more direct heat through the slotted drip tray. An older Lowe’s PG24SG listing described direct-flame grilling up to 650°F.

That does not turn the entire Camp Chef grate into a gas-grill sear station. Grease control, food placement, and flare-up awareness become more important when exposing food to direct flame. For frequent steak searing, a charcoal grill, gas sear burner, or cast-iron cooking surface can still produce a stronger and more predictable crust.

Which grill produces more smoke flavor?

Neither model guarantees stronger smoke flavor in every cook because pellet choice, cooking temperature, airflow, food moisture, and cook time all affect the result.

Pellet grills generally make more visible smoke at lower settings and burn cleaner as the set temperature rises. The original Camp Chef controller includes dedicated smoke settings, while the Pro 575 relies on its D2 controller and does not have Super Smoke. That gives the Camp Chef more smoke-setting control on paper, but it would be dishonest to promise that every meal will taste smokier without a controlled side-by-side test.

Which Grill Is Easier to Clean and Maintain?

The Traeger is simpler because it has less rack area, while the Camp Chef offers a convenient ash cleanout but has more surfaces and moving hardware to maintain.

Camp Chef’s ash cleanout cup can reduce the work of removing routine fire-pot ash. It does not replace periodic vacuuming inside the barrel. Ash can settle outside the cup, and grease still collects on the drip system and other surfaces. Slide and Grill components also need to move freely and remain correctly positioned.

The Traeger requires grate cleaning, grease-bucket care, drip-tray cleaning or liner replacement, and periodic ash removal from around the fire pot. It is not maintenance-free, but the smaller rack system means less cooking surface to scrub.

Whichever grill you choose:

• Keep pellets dry and do not leave swollen pellets in the hopper or auger.
• Follow the full shutdown cycle instead of unplugging a hot grill.
• Remove excess ash after several cooks and before a long session.
• Clean grease before it becomes a fire risk.
• Keep the controller and pellet hopper protected from rain.
• Use a cover only after the grill is cool and dry.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Each Pellet Grill?

The Traeger offers the more consistent smart-grill package, while the Camp Chef offers more rack capacity and physical cooking features at the cost of model confusion and extra cleanup.

Traeger Pro 575 pros

• WiFIRE is included rather than dependent on the version.
• Good capacity for typical household meals.
• Smaller rack system is easier to clean.
• 18-pound hopper is adequate for many cooks.
• 500°F maximum controller setting.
• Official support documentation and compatible parts are easy to identify.

Traeger Pro 575 cons

• Much smaller upper rack than the Camp Chef.
• One included food probe rather than two.
• No Super Smoke mode.
• No dedicated direct-flame system.
• App convenience is less valuable if WiFi is weak near your cooking area.

Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 pros

• 811 square inches of total rack space on the original PG24SG listing.
• Large 382-square-inch upper rack.
• 22-pound pellet hopper.
• Two included food probes on the original PG24SG.
• Ash cleanout and pellet-purge features.
• Slide and Grill gives it more direct-heat flexibility.

Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 cons

• The model name does not reliably tell you which controller is installed.
• WiFi is not included on every SG 24 version.
• More rack area creates more cleaning work.
• Older inventory or used examples require careful inspection.
• The app experience is less straightforward to compare because versions differ.

Who Should Buy the Traeger Pro 575?

Buy the Traeger Pro 575 if you value remote temperature control, usually cook for a household rather than a crowd, and want fewer questions about which controller you are getting.

It is the better fit for a first-time pellet-grill buyer who wants a documented app system and does not need a huge upper rack. It also makes sense if you frequently cook weeknight chicken, burgers, vegetables, pork chops, or one main barbecue cut at a time.

Skip it if you regularly need multiple cooking levels, want direct-flame access, or do not care about WiFi. If you are shopping among newer Traeger designs, also compare the Traeger Woodridge pellet grill before deciding.

Who Should Buy the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24?

Buy the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 if rack capacity, two-probe monitoring, ash cleanout, and Slide and Grill matter more to you than having one clearly defined app package.

It is especially attractive for ribs, chicken pieces, sausages, sides, and larger cooks that can use the generous upper rack. It also suits an owner who understands pellet-grill maintenance and is willing to verify the exact controller.

Skip it if you dislike model-number research, cook small meals most of the time, or are considering an older used example without seeing it operate. A bargain price is not a bargain if the auger, fan, igniter, controller, or temperature probe needs immediate replacement.

What Should You Check Before Buying Either Grill?

Check the exact model, included controller, current warranty terms, replacement-part availability, and the condition of every electrical and pellet-feed component before buying.

For a new grill, compare the seller’s model number with the manufacturer documentation and verify what the warranty covers. For a used pellet grill, ask for a cold startup and let it reach a stable cooking temperature. Listen to the auger and fan, confirm ignition, test all probe ports, inspect the fire pot and drip tray, and make sure the shutdown cycle completes.

Do not compare these grills by an old suggested price. Availability and seller pricing can change, and the original Camp Chef may appear as used equipment or remaining inventory. Compare the actual out-the-door cost with any missing cover, shelf, probe, or replacement controller included in your budget. If neither model fits, the guide to pellet grills priced below $300 shows what a lower budget usually changes.

What Is the Final Verdict?

The Traeger Pro 575 is the better choice for WiFi convenience and ordinary family cooking; the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 is the better choice for rack capacity, direct-flame flexibility, and larger backyard cooks.

Choose the Traeger Pro 575 if you want WiFIRE, a manageable cooking chamber, straightforward manufacturer support, and enough space for most weekly meals.

Choose the Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 if you will actually use its large upper rack, want the bigger hopper and two probes, and have verified the controller on the exact grill being sold.

My decision would come down to use, not the badge on the lid. For a household that values phone control, I would take the Traeger. For frequent rib, pork, chicken, or party cooks, I would take the Camp Chef’s extra capacity—provided the model, condition, and price all check out.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which grill has more cooking space?

The Camp Chef SmokePro SG 24 has more total rack space: 811 square inches versus the Traeger support guide’s measured total of 572 square inches. Most of the Camp Chef advantage is on its upper rack.

Why is the Traeger called the Pro 575 if its grates total 572 square inches?

Traeger markets the grill as having 575 square inches, while its support guide lists a 418-square-inch main grate and 154-square-inch upper grate, totaling 572. The small difference has no meaningful effect on cooking capacity.

Does every Camp Chef SG 24 include WiFi?

No. Camp Chef confirms that not all of its pellet grills include WiFi, and SG 24 listings can refer to different controller versions. Verify the model number and controller rather than relying on the grill name.

Which grill is better for beginners?

The Traeger Pro 575 is the easier recommendation for beginners who want app control because WiFIRE is standard and its smaller cooking system is simple to manage. Buyers who prioritize capacity may still prefer the Camp Chef.

Which grill is better for ribs and brisket?

The Camp Chef is better for multiple racks of ribs and larger mixed cooks because it has more upper-rack space. For one brisket on the main grate, the difference is smaller because the two lower grates are close in area.

Can either pellet grill sear a steak?

Both can cook steak, but the Camp Chef has the advantage because Slide and Grill can expose food to more direct flame. Neither automatically matches a dedicated charcoal grill or gas sear burner for intense, even crust formation.

Which grill is easier to clean?

The Traeger has less rack area to scrub. The Camp Chef’s ash cleanout is convenient, but its larger racks and Slide and Grill hardware still require regular cleaning and inspection.

What accessories are most useful for these pellet grills?

A fitted cover, instant-read thermometer, heat-resistant gloves, ash vacuum, grease-tray supplies, and dry pellet storage are more useful than buying every optional attachment. See the pellet grill accessories guide for practical choices.

Affiliate disclosure: Everything Grill Reviews may earn a commission from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. That does not change the comparison or the price you pay.